Skip to main content

May No Act of Ours Bring Shame

For the glory of old State,
For her founders strong and great,
For the future that we wait,
Raise the song, raise the song.

Sing our love and loyalty,
Sing out hopes that, bright and free,
Rest, O Mother dear, with thee,
All with thee, all with thee

When we stood at childhood's gate,
Shapeless in the hands of fate,
Thou didst mold us, dear old State,
Dear old State, dear old State

May no act of ours bring shame,
To one heart that loves they name,
May our lives but swell thy fame,
Dear old State, dear old State."


If you don't immediately know what this is, I'm pretty sure you're at the wrong school. When I think about all the Penn State stuff that I have, I realize I might like Penn State too much... I mean, who really needs a Penn State sweatshirt, two Penn State crew necks, two Penn State mugs, numerous (I seriously have no idea how many) Penn State shirts, a Penn State water bottle, a Penn State binder, Penn State folders, and Penn State parents. Yeah, I'm not really sure I could've gone anywhere else.

But despite all this Penn State pride, there's always that one piece of history that makes any of us falter. I am, of course, talking about Jerry Sandusky and the failure of Penn State faculty to act when told about his sexual assaults. It can never be justified and it will always be a mark on Penn State's reputation. Penn State should have been a powerful example of why sexual assault claims should be investigated. 

But of course this world isn't perfect.

In light of the recent Lawrence Nassar conviction, Michigan State University has come under scrutiny for failing to fully investigate the numerous complaints that were issued against him years prior to 2016. A very quick summary of Nassar: He is a renowned physician who also was a physician for the Olympics gymnastics team who was accused by 156 women of sexual assualt; he has been sentenced to 40-175 years.What I can't comprehend, and will probably never comprehend, is why no one legitimately investigated him. Penn State's controversy was not that long ago...

But the purpose of this post isn't to lambaste the University. Instead, the focus is on the students of Michigan State. College students and their desire for expression have become something of a controversy, since they trivialize serious issues or promote a closed-minded collection of individuals. In fact, every year Forbes releases an article about the "Most Ridiculous College Protests."

The students at the college created a congregation to support the sexual assault survivors. It was initially going to be a protest for the president, Lou Anna Simon, to resign. However, it was changed to become a message of support. While both messages seem equally viable, I really have to say that I think the support for the sexual assault survivors is an incredible route to take. It changes the overall mood of the students from negative to a positive one. The article quotes a student, Mackenzie Mrla, who says "We're not going to choose what our university did and be silent. We're going to choose to use our words for change. We need change." First of all, this quote cuts deep. If Mackenzie's parents were ever to put something up on their refrigerator, it should be this quote. That first sentence of this quote perfectly conveys the maturity and bitterness of the students at MSU. 


By refusing to kneel to the criticism the college has been receiving, but instead using this opportunity to create a message of support and togetherness illustrates just how powerful student expression can be. These students didn't bury their heads in shame. They're not letting this define MSU. They're creating their own message. And it's a message that is vastly distinct from that of the faculty. These college students are practicing a freedom of expression. I think if they had our alma mater, with the line "May no act of ours bring shame," no one would argue that the MSU students are bringing shame. If anything, they're restoring any credibility the college has at the moment. Not every student gather exists because Millennials are overly sensitized. Not every student gathering exists because "oh it's been pretty quiet recently, so we better protest something." It's not like every single protest is just picking a slip  of paper out of a hat, in which the topics have been decided by using Ctrl-F "Cringe" on Tumblr posts. And even if they were, I think the importance comes down to one question: Even if only one out of every 50 protests is about something serious, and even if only 1 out of those every 50 protests actually accomplishes something, isn't it worth it?

Ok, so it absolutely makes sense that a college wants to shut down student gatherings since it has a reputation to uphold. But, the issue of free speech will always rise up in these types of conversations. In fact, Pennsylvania legislators met last week to see if there is a need to ensure that PA colleges don't exert too much power in controlling speech. Even if you don't go out and shout and scream about issues (I know I'm not one of those people), I think we all could still recognize the frustration of an institution imposing regulations that prevented protests. And if you are one of those protesters, keep shouting.

Comments

  1. Wow, I remember hearing about Nassar and his trial last week, but I hadn't heard about the protests going on at Michigan State to support the sexual assault victims. That is truly amazing that the students are using their freedom of speech to voice their support and verbally condemn Nassar's actions. I especially like the tweet photo you included where the student said that the students are the true representatives of what it means to be a Spartan. I feel like that speaks volumes to both their message and who they are as a student body.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the use of our alma mater for this is super clever! But then again, I wonder how Penn State feels about naming a library and honors program after someone involved in the Sandusky scandal...oh well, leave better than we came, right?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like how you chose to highlight good doings in the world rather than the atrocities that caused them. It’s time we make a positive change rather than sit back while this things happen. I like the angle and approach of your blog post! Keep it up.

    ReplyDelete
  4. When I heard about MSU's role as an enabler of Larry Nassar, my mind immediately drew parallels to Sandusky and Paterno at Penn State. I think the difference we saw between the student reactions to the two events gives me hope that, in the past few years, college students have adopted a more mature view on sexual assault and the people who enable it. I can't help but wonder what the student reaction at Penn State would be if the Sandusky scandal happened today. Has the national attitude shifted enough, or would students (and alumni) still rally around Paterno like they did in 2012?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Matt! I wrote my blog last week on the effects of the women gymnasts who were affected by Larry Nassar, and I am glad I got to read about in from the MSU perspective. I had no idea the students were protesting and it really uplifting to see students taking a stand to support sexual assault victims, instead of protesting their university. With all the events happening with the "#meetoo" and Time's Up movement, I and a lot of other men and women are ready for this time of change. Your blog dives into not only the issues but how it relates to government and free speech. There was actually a rowdy protest today by the Hub. How do you think people feel about protests that are not spreading a positive message? How can we handle situations that could turn ugly in terms of protecting free speech? I'm excited to read what's next!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Where Are the Student Leaders Really Coming From?

This has been a really big week for student expression. It has reached even national levels of importance. It has been the headline for news. But it's not even about college.  Rather, high school student self-expression and protest has taken the nation by storm. This certainly diverges from what one normally expects when hearing student protest. And this is meant to be a blog that is dedicated to examining the issues of college students, but every recent news article is dominated by the protest that just occurred. And, to be quite honest, I would be remiss to neglect something so important to student protest. If you have no idea what I'm talking about, it's pretty simple. Across the country, students filed out of their classes at 10:00 am and remained outside of their classes for 17 minutes. It was a symbolic 17 minutes for the 17 lives lost during the Florida shooting. View out of my window of #NationalWalkoutDay student protest in Madison. pic.twitter.com/jeeq2sCV...

Better Have My Money!

There's a scandal afoot. The students are not happy. The students are fed up with the administration. The students are protesting. The students of Howard University are displaying self-expression, but this time the faculty are at the receiving end of it. Although it seems surprising, this type of protest hasn't been covered yet on this blog. According to the New York Times , hundreds of students occupied the main administration building. Apparently, members of the financial aid office have been embezzling money. As expected, this outraged the students, prompting the current occupation. However, the students also took this time to create a list of 9 different demands. Among some of those demands were to disarm the police on campus, provide better housing for students, and to fight against rape culture. We are unstoppable, another world is possible ✊🏾 #StudentPowerHU pic.twitter.com/V1tT7qsMtm — #StudentPowerHU (@HUResist) April 7, 2018 Courtesy of @HUResit It ...

March for Our Expression

Believe it or not, most of the news focusing on student self-expression is still dominated by things like the student walkout and the gun control march. This again makes it a little hard to focus on just college students' self-expression, but regardless it's important to investigate the consequences. The last blog we looked specifically at school administration relations with the student body in terms of walking out, so this week we'll look at some responses to the marches.  On Saturday, March 24 people around America flooded the streets in a political protest. According to the New York Times , there were marches in 390 of the 495 congressional districts. That is difficult to imagine such a cohesive act across the nation. Even more interesting, this was a largely student-run movement. Here in State College, the march began at the high school and ended on Old Main. I participated in the March, not for personal reasons, but primarily because my friend feels very strong...